J.Renee Women''s Rory Mule

The leather in this shoe is gorgeous---shiny and very black. I''m giving them a 4 for the leather quality alone. My problem with the shoe was the fit. Yes, mules mayslightly "leave" the foot at the heel when you walk, but these actually "flapped" like flip-flops. It seemed that there was too much leather in the width. I''m normally a medium and the width seemed more appropriate for a wide-width.Too bad as I really liked the style of the shoe. (Couldn''t have downsized by a half as the length of the shoe would have been too short.)